Traditional Method
Wash, halve, and pit the plums. Place them in a heavy-bottomed saucepan.
Cook uncovered over low heat, stirring regularly, until the fruit collapses and reduces to a very thick, dark plum butter, about 90 minutes or longer depending on moisture.
Taste near the end and add a small amount of sugar only if needed; add cinnamon if desired. Continue cooking until fully dissolved and thick.
Transfer the hot plum butter to clean heat-safe jars and cool.
Because this traditional source does not provide a validated filled-jar processing schedule, refrigerate promptly or freeze with suitable expansion headspace. Do not store this version at room temperature.